Comments on Kamal Shah's Blog: The deed is done!

I know this is a way too late to comment on this, ...

2009-04-27T00:01:00.000+05:30

I know this is a way too late to comment on this, but I am catching up with your blog now I want to offer my 2 cents:

This idea of 'Wasting your vote' - follow the majority to give value to your vote is scary to me. How can a vote be waste? Each vote is of same value - that's democracy. The outcome of it may be the party or idea you agree with doesn't come to power. But that's again is democracy for you.

Changing who we vote for based on who will have more chance of forming a government is a convoluted thinking. It reminds me of Nietzsche's quote I came across recently

"The surest way to corrupt a youth is to instruct him to hold in higher esteem those who think alike than those who think differently"

Disclaimer: I didn't vote, I live too far away from a polling booth. But I am just pissed at the logic of selecting a leader.

Thanks Santu! I agree with a lot of what you've s...

2009-04-18T14:06:00.000+05:30

Thanks Santu!

I agree with a lot of what you've said. But my vote was more for Aarogyasri, the brilliant medical insurance plan that the Y S Rajasekhar Reddy government has started.

I have a written a lot on this in earlier posts. This scheme has really benefited a lot of people.

Medicine is at a stage where many people continue to die due to unknown problems in spite of having a lot of money.

When that is the shape of things, having to die of a condition for which there is a well-known treatment just because someone does not have the money is really, really sad.

I have myself seen some people who had renal failure and died simply because they just could not afford dialysis.

Aarogyasri provides any poor person dialysis twice a week at any hospital (including the corporate hospitals that have better facilities than government hospitals). This is the difference between life and death for such individuals.

And what did it take?

Some creative thinking and support from the government.

My vote is solely for this scheme which a certain Mr. Naidu has threatened to replace with another scheme. Why? Why not continue with this scheme and tweak it to remove the defects? This kind of replacement of this scheme is going to cause untold hardship to a large number of people.

My vote is for Aarogyasri and nothing else. You might accuse me of being narrow minded and worrying only about one aspect of governance.

So be it. This is dear to my heart!

A very valid choice for the center. Though I did d...

2009-04-17T18:55:00.000+05:30

A very valid choice for the center. Though I did differ with you for the state's choice by voting for the "mahakutami" candidate from my constituency. This was the first time, I was voting for a combine and not a specific party or candidate.

With what ever has been happening in the center and the way there have been serious compromises in the way the central leadership handled many of the internal and foreign affairs, hence a vote for the Congress is an utter denial for progress.

1. The center spends crores of dollars in building road links in Taliban infested Afghanistan, whereas my city's local roads are in apathy.
2. It has allowed a former ally and close neighbour in Nepal to be infested and ruled by Maoists, with complete control by China
3. Complete failure of the public distribution system in spite of a much above average monsoon and harvest.
4. Absolute apathy in handling the security council issue of publicly humiliating an Indian national for election to the UN Secretary General post.
5. Poor handling of internal security
6. Absolute mishandling of the government machinery in handling many important posts
7. Non progressive non-minority uplifting policies, just namesake minority appeasement
8. Complete breakdown of the political will in managing its own political allies. Almost all of them have broken off the so called UPA combine
9. Mishandling of the Singur situation

Besides this, there are many other issues which a party like Congress, which has ruled over India for over 80% of the time since independence can afford to do.

Hence the choice for a change that "may" provide the leadership that is required to lead a country like India the next 5 years.

!! VOTE BJP !!

Yes, that's what I did, BJP at the center and Cong...

2009-04-17T12:16:00.000+05:30

Yes, that's what I did, BJP at the center and Congress in the state.

My Facebook status was only about the center.

Voting for the BJP in the LokSabha polls has some ...

2009-04-17T12:07:00.000+05:30

Voting for the BJP in the LokSabha polls has some logic, since there is a chance they can either form a govt or influence who forms one.

At the state level they are a NOBODY. Waste of a vote. Thought that you were voting Congress (YSR) for the Arogyasri plan at the State level.